Mornings with Dave & Jen

How to shut down unwanted advice

Photo: clipart.com, WYXL 97.3 Lite Rock

How to shut down unwanted advice

We’ve all been there.

You’re nursing a mistake or wrestling with a tough decision when suddenly someone swoops in with “helpful” advice you never asked for. Instead of feeling supported, you feel judged and second-guessed.

CNBC has some phrases you can use to shut down unsolicited advice from others:

‘Thanks for sharing. I’ll consider it.’

This is a polite way to acknowledge someone’s input without locking yourself in. It keeps the peace and acknowledges the other person’s contribution, while keeping the decision-making power firmly with you.

This is the softest boundary, best in instances like a colleague weighing in on how you should run your project, or a relative chiming in about your personal choices.

It is ideal for professional and personal contexts where you want to stay courteous, but not invite any more input.

‘That’s a useful view. I prefer to handle it this way.’

This shows you’re listening to their perspective while keeping the choice of how to act in your hands. It balances respect while honoring your own autonomy, and research shows that protecting autonomy is key to wellbeing, motivation, and self-belief.

This is ideal when the advice-giver is senior to you, maybe a boss or mentor. It lets you acknowledge their authority while standing firm in your approach. It’s useful when you haven’t made a decision yet, but know the direction you want.

That said, if the advice comes from someone with more experience or oversight, it may make sense to follow their direction unless you have a very strong reason not to. You could add add a brief explanation: “I prefer to handle it this way, and here’s why…”

‘I appreciate your input. I already have a plan for how I’ll move forward.’

This respectfully closes the loop while signaling you’ve got things under control. It also reduces the chance that they’ll keep offering repeat advice because you’ve been clear about having a direction.

Use this for repeated or insistent advice, like a coworker who keeps pushing their “better way” of doing something, or a family member who doesn’t trust you to make your own choices.

It’s a firmer step up from “That’s a useful view. I prefer to handle it this way,” because it explicitly states that you already have a plan.

‘That means a lot. Right now I’d really value support more than solutions.’

This reframes the interaction by guiding them toward what you do need, which is emotional support instead of instruction. It channels their good intentions while protecting your sense of control.

It shines in personal situations, like when friends or family jump in with advice, but what you really need is empathy, and someone to listen.

Research finds that emotional support often help us feel better when we’re stressed, while solution-giving can sometimes miss the mark or even backfire.

‘I hear you. If I need more guidance, I’ll reach out.’

This validates their effort but sets a clear boundary. This approach prevents further unsolicited input while leaving the door open for you to seek advice on your terms.

It’s useful when you need to firmly close the conversation, like when you’re getting bombarded with “shoulds” at work, or when someone keeps overstepping in your personal life.

One important thing to keep in mind: Tone changes everything. The very same words can come across as gracious or defensive depending on how you deliver them. Aim for calm, steady, and respectful. That’s what makes these responses work.

Advice will always come, whether you want it to or not. At work, at home, in the grocery line, even at the gym. Your power lies in how you receive it.

Dave & Jen Podcasts

Walden Place: Senior Isolation

The risks of senior isolation

Team Rubicon’s Larysa Murray

Meet Team Rubicon’s Larysa Murray

Special Olympics Polar Plunge

The Ithaca Polar Plunge is back!

Tax preparation for seniors

Tax preparation for seniors

Walden Place: Memory care

Learn more about Walden Place’s Embrace Memory Care

More Podcasts

Recent Headlines

16 hours ago in Community, Lifestyle, Local, Politics

Richford board approves woodchips purchase

On March 10, the Richford Town Board Town agreed to spend up to $3,000 on woodchips at the Rawley Park playground.

17 hours ago in Entertainment

‘Stand by Me’ stars reflect on the movie, Rob Reiner and its return to theaters 40 years later

Jerry O'Connell, Corey Feldman and Wil Wheaton were already thinking about "Stand by Me" when Rob Reiner died in December. Just a week prior, the trio spent a weekend together attending some screenings of Reiner's beloved coming-of-age film, which was about to turn 40.

18 hours ago in Sports, Trending

March Madness: Here’s one thing you need to know about each of the 16 teams remaining in men’s field

Florida isn't around to defend its title anymore, but all the other top seeds in this year's NCAA Tournament are still around. And many of them are winning convincingly.

18 hours ago in Entertainment

Stephen Colbert and son will co-write a ‘Lord of the Rings’ movie

Stephen Colbert, famous devotee to J.R.R. Tolkien's Middle Earth, is co-writing a "Lord of the Rings" movie with his son. Warner Bros. announced early Wednesday that Colbert will script "The Lord of the Rings: Shadow of the Past" along with series veteran Philippa Boyens and Peter McGee, Colbert's son.

22 hours ago in Entertainment, Regional, Sports

Sabres coach praises energetic support entering homestand

The Sabres entertain the Bruins tonight at 7:30 p.m.